Tynan enters her first professional season in the Northern Super League (NSL) with Rise FC after excelling with TSS Rovers over the past two seasons in League1 BC, captaining the team in 2024 and being named Swanguardians Women's Player of the Year. At the collegiate level, Tynan made 58 U Sports starts in net for the Queen’s University Gaels from 2021 to 2024, recording 33 clean sheets. Tynan captained the team in 2023 and 2024, was named a U Sports All-Canadian and OUA First Team All-Star in 2023, and helped the team win the OUA women’s soccer title in 2021. In 2023, Tynan spent time training abroad with English Women’s Super League side Everton FC.